Toilet Rebuild vs. Replacement Guide

If there’s one household feature we heavily rely on and often overlook until there’s an issue, it’s our toilets. Whether it’s that relentless flushing sound, an unwelcome puddle near the base, or a strangely high water bill, toilet problems can’t be ignored. Rocket Plumbing presents a thorough guide on choosing a toilet rebuild or replacing the entire unit. 

Factors Influencing Toilet Rebuilds

  1. Flapper and Fill Valve

Why is a flapper and fill valve important?

The flapper and fill valve are critical components within the toilet tank. The flapper acts as a seal, ensuring water doesn’t perpetually flow into the bowl, which can lead to constant running water and wastage. If the flapper’s functionality is compromised, the fill valve often continues filling the tank, further exacerbating the issue.

Why does a flapper and fill valve break down?

The flapper and fill valve are prone to wear and tear over time. The flapper can deteriorate due to constant exposure to water, leading to a poor seal. The fill valve can accumulate mineral deposits, clog, or wear out over time.

Difficulty of a flapper and fill valve repair or replacement?

Typically, these repairs are straightforward for most DIY enthusiasts. Replacement parts are commonly available, and with a few tools, both components can be replaced without requiring professional help.

  1. Tank Gasket

Why is a tank gasket important?

The tank gasket is a rubber component that provides a watertight seal between the tank and the bowl. When it fails, it can cause significant leaks, which might damage the flooring or the structure beneath.

Why does a tank gasket break down?

Over time, the rubber material can dry out, become brittle, and crack. Additionally, constant water exposure can weaken it, leading to eventual failure.

Difficulty repairing or replacing a tank gasket?

While replacing the gasket itself is relatively simple, the challenge often lies in removing the old tank, especially if the bolts holding it are rusted or stuck. There’s also a risk of cracking the tank during this process, making it a moderately difficult task.


Not sure what you need? Contact us today!


    1. Wax Ring

    Why is a toilet wax ring important?

    The wax ring is located at the toilet’s base and ensures a watertight seal between the toilet and the floor. It also prevents foul sewage gases from entering your bathroom. A failing wax ring can result in water leakage with each flush and a potentially unpleasant odor.

    Why does a toilet wax ring break down?

    With repeated use and over time, the wax can lose its shape and the ability to seal, especially if the toilet rocks or shifts.

    Difficulty of toilet wax ring repair?

    The task involves unmounting the toilet from the floor, which can be cumbersome for many homeowners. It’s considered a moderate-level repair, requiring some plumbing knowledge and physical effort.

    1. Supply Line

    Why is a supply line important?

    The supply line is responsible for channeling water into the toilet tank. A damaged or leaking supply line can lead to consistent water wastage and potential damage around the vicinity.

    Why does a supply line break down?

    Common causes include wear and tear, physical damage, and corrosion due to water quality.

    Difficulty of repairing a supply line?

    Supply line replacements are generally straightforward. However, use care to ensure the correct line type and size are chosen for the replacement.

    1. Age Factor

    Why is age factor an issue to be aware of?

    As toilets age, they might not function as efficiently, may require parts that are hard to source, and may be less water-efficient.

    Reasons and signs of aging and breakdown.

    Frequent use, material degradation, and outdated technology can contribute to the wear and tear of older toilets.

    Difficulty of repair?

    Depending on the specific issue, repairs on older toilets can range from simple to very complex. Sometimes, even after a repair, the toilet might not operate at peak efficiency, leading homeowners to consider a complete replacement for long-term peace of mind.

    white ceramic toilet bowl with cover

    Toilet Rebuild or Replacement: Assessing the Best Route

    When faced with toilet troubles, homeowners often grapple with whether to rebuild or replace. The age of the toilet and the severity of its damage are crucial in this choice. A newer toilet showing minor plumbing issues, such as a malfunctioning flapper or fill valve, typically benefits from a straightforward toilet rebuild.

    On the other hand, the scales might tilt in favor of replacement for those dealing with an old model with nagging issues. Shifting to a modern, water-efficient toilet addresses these persistent issues and offers a wiser financial investment over time, bringing down utility bills and minimizing repair expenses.

    Find Toilet Repair Services Near You

    Professional Assistance with Rocket Plumbing: The Value of Expertise

    Embarking on a DIY repair might offer a sense of achievement, but the nuances of plumbing often necessitate expert intervention. Here’s why considering Rocket Plumbing’s professional service is not only wise but indispensable:

    1. Precision Detection: Details, especially minute ones, matter immensely in plumbing. The trained eyes of Rocket Plumbing technicians can expertly detect even the most elusive hairline cracks in your toilet tank, ensuring that no potential trouble remains hidden.
    2. Handling Aged Components with Finesse: Ageing plumbing components can be challenging for the uninitiated. Rusty bolts? Fragile parts? No worries. With their extensive toolbox and years of hands-on experience, Rocket Plumbing pros navigate these challenges seamlessly, minimizing the risk of exacerbating the issue.
    3. Guaranteed Perfect Fit: In plumbing, precision isn’t just crucial; it’s everything. A misfit part can be the source of inconvenient leaks or inefficiencies. This is why Rocket Plumbing ensures that every component fits snugly and correctly, preventing potential hassles down the line.
    4. Economic in the Long Run: Using a professional might seem like an expenditure at first glance. However, it provides long-term fiscal benefits because homeowners can sidestep recurring complications, conserving money on potential future repairs.

    So, the next time a plumbing problem stares you down, remember: Rocket Plumbing is only a call or click away, standing by to amalgamate expert solutions with unmatched peace of mind.